Skip to main content

CombinedBinHClucAndMADV3 Strategy: The "Trinity" Old Master

Nickname: Quantitative "Trinity" Combo Profession: Multi-Strategy Fusion Trend Hunter Timeframe: 5 Minutes Main + 1 Hour Observational

1. What's This Strategy?​

Simply put, CombinedBinHClucAndMADV3 is a "Trinity" combo strategy — it takes three classic strategies each with its own specialty and throws them together. Whoever has an opportunity, the strategy follows.

Think of it like a medical team:

  • BinHV45 is the ER doctor, specializing in catching "breakout market" emergencies
  • ClucMay72018 is the old-school Chinese medicine doctor, specializing in finding opportunities in "oversold rebounds" chronic conditions
  • MACD Low is the physiotherapist, giving patients a push during the "low-point golden cross" recovery period

Three doctors take turns on duty — whichever department has a patient, that one gets treated 😂

2. Core Settings: "Take the Money and Run"​

Take-Profit Rules (ROI Table)​

minimal_roi = {"0": 0.021}  # Made 2.1%? Out you go!

Translation: Don't be greedy. 2.1% is already pretty sweet — take the money and run!

This strategy is a "quick-draw artist" — no long-term holding, profits and runs, accumulates over time.

Stop-Loss Rules​

stoploss = -0.99  # Hard stop mostly disabled, relies on custom stop-loss

Translation: I don't set a hard stop. I have my own tricks — if I'm not making money after 240 minutes (4 hours), you're out!

Trailing Stop​

trailing_stop = True
trailing_stop_positive = 0.01          # Starts tracking at 1% profit
trailing_stop_positive_offset = 0.025  # Activates at 2.5% profit

Translation:

  • Only when you're up more than 2.5% does the "trailing stop" bodyguard kick in
  • Once active, if price drops 1% from peak, you're cut loose
  • Goal: let profits run, but not too far 😅

3. Three Buy Conditions: Let Me Sort Them Out​

This strategy's buy conditions look complex, but they're really just three "gate guardians," each with its own temperament:

🎯 Category 1: BinHV45 ER Doctor (Breakout Type)​

Core Logic: Wait for price to "squeeze" to the Bollinger lower band, then break back up — this is a "fake drop," get on board!

Plain English:

"This patient (price) just took a fall (hit the lower band), and got back up on their own — clearly fine, let's treat!"

Classic Lines:

  • 1h EMA200 must be rising → "The superior hospital (1-hour trend) says treat"
  • Close < previous BB40 lower band → "Just fell to the ground"
  • Tail < BB bandwidth × 23.3% → "Light fall this time, there's potential"
  • Volume > 0 → "No cheating! Real money votes!"

📉 Category 2: ClucMay72018 Old Chinese Medicine Doctor (Oversold Rebound)​

Core Logic: Price dropped to Bollinger lower band with nobody buying (volume extremely low) — this is "oversold," prepare for rebound!

Plain English:

"Nobody wants this stock anymore (volume extremely low), which means it can't drop further. Time to bottom-fish!"

Classic Lines:

  • Close < BB20 lower band × 0.985 → "1.5% below the bottom price, pretty aggressive!"
  • Volume < 30-day average ÷ 20 → "This volume is colder than Mars"
  • Volume < previous candle × 4 → "75% colder than before, total ice age"

📈 Category 3: MACD Low Physiotherapist (Golden Cross Rebound)​

Core Logic: MACD just had a golden cross (bullish signal), AND price is oversold — this is "back from the dead"!

Plain English:

"The patient is responding! MACD turned from negative to positive (golden cross), and it's still in oversold territory — time for recovery!"

Classic Lines:

  • EMA26 > EMA12 (golden cross) → "MACD in bullish alignment"
  • Difference > open price × 2% → "Golden cross needs to be powerful enough, don't fake it"
  • Volume < previous candle × 4 → "Shrunk again — this time it's real"

4. The Three Conditions' "Personalities" Compared​

ConditionPersonalitySuitable MarketCore Skill
BinHV45ER DoctorTrend start breakoutSpotting "fake falls"
ClucMay72018Old Chinese MedicineOversold bounce in consolidationSpotting "cold coins"
MACD LowPhysiotherapistPost-fall reboundSpotting "golden cross turning points"

Bottom Line: Whoever has an opportunity goes — not picky 😎

5. Exit Logic: Simpler Than Entry​

5.1 The Only Sell Signal: Break Above Bollinger Middle Band​

# Sell condition
(dataframe['close'] > dataframe['bb_middleband'] * 1.01)

Plain English:

"Price broke above the Bollinger middle line — no matter how much we're up, first to run is first to safety!"

This strategy's exit logic is extremely simple: break the middle band and run, regardless of what comes next.

5.2 Trailing Stop: Profit Bodyguard​

  • Before 2.5% profit: Fly freely, rise or fall as you please
  • After 2.5% profit: "Tracking mode" on — if price drops 1%, cut loose

5.3 Time Stop-Loss: Iron Discipline​

# Holding > 240 minutes (4 hours) AND at a loss? Out!
if (current_profit < 0) & (holding > 240 minutes):
    return 0.01  # Cut loose!

Plain English:

"Held for over 4 hours and still not making money — I misjudged this one, accept the loss and get out!"

6. The Strategy's "Personality Traits"​

✅ Pros​

  1. Trinity: Three strategies combined, one always fits the current market
  2. Multi-Timeframe: Not just 5 minutes, also 1 hour — double insurance
  3. Volume Filtering: Requires volume contraction, effectively filters "false breakouts"
  4. Iron Stop-Loss: 4-hour time stop-loss avoids long-term traps
  5. Simple and Brutal: Exit logic is super simple, no overthinking

⚠️ Cons​

  1. Take-Profit Too Conservative: Only 2.1% and out, might miss big moves
  2. Trend-Dependent: BinHV45 requires EMA uptrend, rare signals in bear markets
  3. Exit Too Early: Break the middle band and run, might sell too soon
  4. Condition Conflicts: When all three are enabled, they might contradict each other

7. When to Use It?​

Market EnvironmentRecommended ActionReason
Trending UpFocus on BinHV45Many breakout signals, easy to catch the main rally
Range-BoundFocus on ClucMay72018Oversold rebounds are great in consolidation
Fast Drop + ReboundFocus on MACD LowRebound opportunities are a sure thing
SidewaysEnable all threeDon't know which will win, try them all

8. Summary: How Good Is This Strategy Really?​

One-Line Verdict​

"The quantitative 'Trinity' quick-draw artist: makes 2.1% and runs, cuts losses after 4 hours if losing"

Who Should Use It?​

  • ✅ Steady players who like accumulating small gains
  • ✅ Laid-back traders who don't want to watch the screen all night
  • ✅ Quantitative beginners who want simple and brutal approaches
  • ✅ Diversified investors who like multi-strategy combos

Who Should NOT?​

  • ❌ Get-rich-quick risk-takers
  • ❌ Long-term value investors
  • ❌ Soft-hearted folks who can't accept selling a rising coin
  • ❌ Bottom-fishers in bear markets

9. What Markets Does This Strategy Make Money In?​

9.1 Core Logic: Building a "Protection Net" with "Three Doctors"​

CombinedBinHClucAndMADV3 is a classic "multi-strategy fusion" design in the Freqtrade ecosystem. About 150 lines of code, three doctors take turns, whoever's up to it treats.

Its money-making philosophy:

  • BinHV45: Trend's here? Break out! Don't hesitate, go for it! 🚀
  • ClucMay72018: Nobody wants it? Bottom-fish! Wait for the wind! 🌪️
  • MACD Low: Indicators turning positive? Get in! Don't wait to miss it! ⚡

9.2 Performance by Market (Plain English)​

Market TypeRatingPlain English
Trending Up⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐All three conditions fire, especially BinHV45 — straight to the moon
Trending Down⭐⭐☆☆☆1h EMA200 downward, BinHV45 conditions completely broken, signals rare
Range-Bound⭐⭐⭐☆☆ClucMay72018 and MACD Low catch rebounds, but moves aren't big
High Volatility⭐⭐⭐☆☆Many signals but also lots of noise, needs stronger filtering

Bottom Line:

"Makes a fortune in bull markets, tinkers in volatile markets, goes dormant in bear markets"

10. ⚠️ Risk Re-Emphasis (Must Read!)​

Backtesting Looks Great, Live Trading Is Different​

CombinedBinHClucAndMADV3's historical backtesting often looks quite good — but there's a trap:

Because all three conditions can trigger signals, the strategy can easily be "selectively correct" in certain market conditions, but that doesn't guarantee future profitability.

Simply put: Three doctors and one of them is always bound to guess right — but which one isn't predictable!

Hidden Risks of Combo Strategies​

In live trading, complex logic can cause:

  • Signal Conflicts: All three conditions met simultaneously — which one do you trust?
  • Overfitting: The combo may perform exceptionally in certain specific conditions, buta different market it falls apart
  • Selling Too Soon: 2.1% and out — could easily miss a 10x coin
  • 4-Hour Trap: Time stop-loss might cut your position right before dawn

My Suggestions (Genuinely)​

1. Paper trade for 3 months first, only go live after confirming stability
2. Don't start with full position — add 10% at a time
3. Watch the 1-hour trend — trade less when trend is down
4. Have stop-loss discipline ready — don't manually intervene in the strategy
5. Review periodically — see how the strategy performs in current markets

Remember: Strategies are rigid, markets are fluid. Test with small positions — survival is what matters! 🙏

Final Reminder: This strategy's "fast in, fast out" style really does suit many scenarios. But even the best strategy can't survive parameter tampering. Set it and step back — let the strategy run itself!

Good luck trading, and may you achieve financial freedom soon! 🚀💰

This document is written based on the CombinedBinHClucAndMADV3 strategy source code.